Is Eagle Rare Becoming More Rare At The Buffalo Trace Distillery Gift Shop??

The question of whether Eagle Rare bourbon is becoming more rare at the Distillery Gift Shop is an interesting one, especially for bourbon enthusiasts and collectors. To delve deeper into this topic, let’s analyze the data.

Comparing the sales data for Eagle Rare bourbon between year-to-date 2023 and the same period in the previous year, January 1st, 2022, to September 25, 2022. This analysis will provide insights into whether Eagle Rare is becoming more or less rare in the market.

Year-to-Date Sales Comparison (2023 vs. 2022):

In order to assess the rarity of Eagle Rare, we need to focus on the sales data for this specific brand in both years:

Eagle Rare Sales in 2023:

  • Total Sales: 42 days available at the gift shop, accounting for 15.67% of the time available during this period.

Eagle Rare Sales in 2022:

  • Total Sales: 61 days available at the gift shop, making up 25.63% of the time available during the same period.

Analyzing the Data:

  1. Percentage of Days Available: In 2023, Eagle Rare accounts for 15.67% of the time available, whereas in 2022, it represented 25.63%. This indicates a decrease in the market share of Eagle Rare within the given timeframe.
  2. Days Available: Eagle Rare sold 42 days in 2023, compared to 61 days in 2022. This is a significant drop in sales volume over the same period.

Factors Influencing the Change:

One significant factor that repeatedly emerges as a key contributor to this evolving trend pertains to the availability of Eagle Rare bottles. There appears to be a discernible supply chain challenge associated with Eagle Rare, potentially impacting its presence in the market. However, it’s imperative to delve deeper into this issue and consider whether it’s solely related to the bottling process or if it reflects a more intricate aspect of the brand’s inventory management.

Eagle Rare distinguishes itself by its extended aging process of 10 years, setting it apart from other allocated bottles in terms of maturity and flavor profile. This prolonged aging period not only underscores the brand’s commitment to quality but also raises intriguing questions about its inventory management. Is the challenge primarily tied to the bottling process, leading to a potential backlog of stock awaiting packaging? Conversely, could it signify a more fundamental issue—a shortage of aged bourbon barrels in their inventory?

As we continue to monitor this trend, it will be fascinating to ascertain whether these supply chain complexities persist. If it turns out to be primarily a bottling issue, we might expect inventory levels to gradually increase as they catch up with production. However, if the root cause lies in a scarcity of aged bourbon stock, it could signal a longer-term challenge for Eagle Rare’s availability and could potentially prompt adjustments in production or sourcing strategies.


Based on the available sales data, it appears that Eagle Rare has become relatively rarer in the year-to-date period of 2023 compared to the same timeframe in 2022. This is reflected in both its reduced percentage of days available and lower number of days available. However, to fully understand the reasons behind these changes, unfortunately only the Buffalo Trace Distillery truly knows the comprehensive picture of Eagle Rare’s evolving rarity.

Data Set

January 1st, 2023 – September 25, 2023

E.H. Taylor, Jr. Small Batch6925.75%
Eagle Rare4215.67%
W.L. Weller Special Reserve7628.36%

January 1st, 2022 – September 25, 2022

E.H. Taylor, Jr. Small Batch5422.69%
Eagle Rare6125.63%
W.L. Weller Special Reserve5322.27%

2 thoughts on “Is Eagle Rare Becoming More Rare At The Buffalo Trace Distillery Gift Shop??

  1. Interesting, however in certain parts of the country it is more available. So could it be that BT is trying to get more of it in peoples hands?

  2. I’d love to know if the quantities that BT has available on a given day are the same? The sell-out timeframes seem to vary considerably (even for a particular brand on a specific day of the week), so it looks like they may release more on some days? Any info folks have would be appreciated!

Leave a Reply